THE QUANTUM LEAP NIT-PICKER'S GUIDE

Season 2, Episode #7:  "Thou Shalt Not"

(Copyright 1997; this guide may not be reproduced in any form without permission of the editors.)

Leap Dates:  Saturday, 2 Feb 1974 to ? (fairly soon after Joe punches Sam
out--Sam still has a split lip at the graveside ceremony)

HOLOGRAMMATICAL ERRORS:

Hologrammatical Error #1:  When Al is teaching Sam the hora, Al’s image reflects in the dance floor--can’t miss them golden slippers! (MPB)

Hologrammatical Error #2:  It was a bit windy in the Imaging Chamber when Al was talking to Sam on the beach. (IMZ)
PCR: Perhaps a wind illusion is created to make it easier for Sam to interact with Al without being distracted by the differences in their environments. As Sam became more and more reliant on Al, the fact that he could not touch or interact in any tangible way would become very discouraging for Sam. Sam’s support team back at PQL probably decided to make the holographic image reflect Sam’s environment as much as possible in order to reduce the distress that his temporal exile must be causing Sam. (SVZ, NM)
Anti-PCR: If that’s the case, Al is the worst violator of such an effort. Al himself often takes a pretty cavalier attitude toward maintaining the illusion, and sometimes goes out of his way to aggravate Sam by walking through things, floating in air, popping in and out unannounced, etc. (IMZ, MPB)

BACKSTORY NITS:

Sam Backstory Nit #1:  Sam’s a doctor. Why did he seem so squeamish at Al’s mention of circumcision? (LW)
PCR #1:  Either Sam swiss-cheesed his medical degree, or he was just showing a standard male reaction at the thought of performing (or undergoing) such a delicate operation. Even if Sam did remember some of his medical training, he might not have felt confident that he remembered enough to perform a circumcision. (HJK & MPB)
PCR #2: Not all medical doctors are trained in surgery. Ob-gyns often do circumcisions. We know from "Genesis" that Sam is not an ob-gyn. (TA)

HISTORICAL NITS:

Historical Nit #1: Another temporal paradox here: if Sam had not been there, wouldn’t Heimlich have died, and therefore not been around to invent the Heimlich maneuver that Sam uses to rescue Heimlich? (LW)
PCR: Maybe in timeline #1 (pre-Sam), Dr. Heimlich chokes, passes out, and almost dies, but is ultimately rescued from impending death--perhaps by somebody manually extracting the stuck object. Dr. Heimlich says to himself, "Hmmmm....there’s gotta be a better way to deal with these situations," studies the matter, and comes up with his famous maneuver.  In the Sam-created timeline, Sam speeds the process up and spares Dr. Heimlich a near-death experience. (Heimlich did, by the way, invent his "maneuver" in 1974). If Sam, in the course of this Leap, accelerates the discovery of the Heimlich maneuver, he may have saved many more lives than just Dr. Heimlich’s--a little bonus to this Leap. (MPB, LW)

GENERAL NITPICKING:

General Nit # 1: How did Sam get through the rest of Karen’s bat-mitzvah service? (LW)
PCR: Maybe most of the rabbi’s part was finished by the time Sam Leaped in. Perhaps the cantor led the rest of the service. (HJK)

General Nit #2: An uncle in a close-knit family would not have to ask his niece whether she played the guitar or how to get to the beach house. Yet neither Karen nor her parents showed surprise at Sam’s questions. (LW)
PCR #1:  Perhaps Karen was too disturbed by her parents’ behavior to pick up on Sam’s flub. (MPB)
PCR #2:  Perhaps Karen and her parents attributed Sam/David’s odd questions and hesitation to his own discomfort about Danny’s death (HJK)
PCR #3: As a rabbi, David probably had a pretty busy schedule. If he rarely had a chance to go to the beach house, it wouldn’t be surprising if he couldn’t remember how to get there. Even Joe and Irene hadn’t been there in a year. (HJK)
PCR #4: Perhaps David had a lousy memory for directions, so it didn’t seem odd that he had to ask, even if he’d been there before. (HJK)

General Nit #2: Why would Sam have so much trouble faking his way through the hora? As we see later, he’s a pretty good dancer, so it should have been easy for him to pick up from watching the person next to him. If he could tango, the hora should have been a cakewalk. (LW)
PCR #1: Nobody ever seems to be able to do the hora in unison. (HJK)
PCR #2: Sam swiss-cheesed his dancing ability. (MPB)
PCR #3: Al just wanted a chance to show off those golden slippers. (MPB)

General Nit #3: How did Sam keep his yarmulke on when Joe was punching him out? (LW)
PCR: Bobby pins, hair spray, industrial-strength yarmulke clips, and Krazy Glue. (MPB & HJK)

DETAILS, DETAILS, DETAILS:

Detail #1: Like "Disco Inferno," this episode has a brother relationship that parallels Sam’s relationship with Tom. In the gas line, when Joe reminisces about how his dad used to take him and David to sporting events, Sam seems to be trying to stir up memories of his own father and brother. There is also a parallel between Sam and Karen. Sam, too, knows what it’s like to lose an older brother. He can probably relate very well to what Karen feels. One wonders how the Becketts’ reaction to Tom’s death compared with Irene and Joe’s. (MPB)

OH, BOYS:

Sam substitutes an "Oy vey" for his traditional Leap-in "Oh, boy."

AL’S WOMEN:

Al talks a lot here about his third wife Ruthie, who was Jewish, and apparently something special, as he didn’t know what family meant until she’d left him.

NAME THAT TUNE:

"The Locomotion"

"Hava Negila"

"Killing Me Softly" by Roberta Flack--an appropriate choice, considering how Joe’s been treating Irene. (MH & MPB)

FAVORITE QUOTATIONS:

Al:  "What’s wrong with a good old-fashioned one-night stand?"

Al:  "Well, sometimes I think that fidelity is highly overrated…uh...nobody looks at the downside.
Sam:  "There is a downside to being faithful?"
Al:  "Of course. It discourages social interaction. Look Sam, if all the men in the world could freely… socialize with all the women in the world, there would be no war."
Sam:  "Until their wives found out!"

Al:  "My relationships have all been good; it’s my marriages that haven’t worked out."
 
Back            Home